Paris Court Rules Accessibility Overlay Criticism Crossed Line into Unlawful Disparagement
The Paris Judicial Court ordered an accessibility expert to pay €3,000 in damages to FACIL’ITI after finding sweeping online criticism of its overlay solution exceeded legitimate free expression.
On December 11, 2025, the Paris Judicial Court (Tribunal judiciaire de Paris, 5th Chamber, 2nd Section) delivered its judgment in a civil liability dispute between digital accessibility company FACIL’ITI and an independent digital accessibility expert (case number 21/06746).
The court held that categorical and unnuanced public statements posted on social media and a personal blog regarding FACIL’ITI’s assistive software constituted commercial disparagement (dénigrement) under Article 1240 of the French Civil Code, rather than protected critique on a matter of public interest.
Background of the Dispute
FACIL’ITI provides a patented web overlay tool launched in 2015. Offered via monthly subscriptions, the tool customizes website displays according to visual, motor, or cognitive needs without altering underlying source code.
In February 2020, an accessibility expert published an article on GitHub referencing FACIL’ITI as a "magic button" promising accessibility in one click. FACIL’ITI requested the removal of its name, which the author subsequently deleted. However, in October and November 2020, the expert posted tweets and a blog article stating that overlay tools such as FACIL’ITI "absolutely do not make sites accessible" and describing their claims as deceptive marketing.
After a formal cease-and-desist letter went unheeded, FACIL’ITI served a summons on May 6, 2021, seeking civil damages for commercial disparagement. Pre-trial mediation ordered in December 2023 was unsuccessful.
The Parties' Arguments
FACIL’ITI argued that the defendant's publications were malicious, disproportionate, and lacked factual backing. The company maintained that its commercial communications clearly state that its tool does not alter site code, does not replace regulatory compliance under the French accessibility framework (Référentiel général d'amélioration de l'accessibilité, or RGAA), and does not serve non-sighted or deaf users.
The expert countered that her comments were protected by freedom of expression under Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights. She argued that true digital accessibility requires underlying code compliance under RGAA and WCAG standards to cover all disabilities, which overlays fail to provide—a position supported by European Commission and ministerial statements. The expert also lodged a counterclaim for €10,000, alleging that the lawsuit was an abusive attempt to silence public debate.
The Court's Ruling
The court recalled that while public interest debate permits strong critique, disparagement occurs when remarks directed at a specific product lack an adequate factual basis and exceed proportionate expression.
The judgment highlighted that:
Consequently, the court found the defendant liable for disparagement under Article 1240 of the Civil Code.
Outcome and Damages
The court rejected claims of economic loss, noting FACIL’ITI’s annual revenue had doubled from €130,000 to €280,000 between 2020 and 2021. However, it awarded FACIL’ITI €3,000 for non-economic reputational damage, considering the targeted audience and the limited reach of the posts.
The court also:
The decision is enforceable on a provisional basis.
Download for Google Chrome
Download for Edge
Download for Firefox