All news

French Court Rejects Summary Injunction Against Auchan Over E-Commerce Accessibility

A summary court in Lille dismissed claims against Auchan E-commerce France, finding no manifest illegality because the entity fell below the €250 million revenue threshold.

On May 5, 2026, the summary judge of the Judicial Court of Lille (Tribunal judiciaire de Lille) issued an order rejecting emergency applications brought by two disability advocacy associations against SAS Auchan E-commerce France concerning accessibility defects on its website and mobile app.

Background of the Dispute

The action was initiated by ApiDV and Droit Pluriel, two non-profit organizations advocating for the rights of persons with disabilities, particularly visually impaired users. Following a formal notice sent on July 9, 2025, the associations served a summons on November 24, 2025. They requested emergency summary relief under Article 835 of the French Code of Civil Procedure to halt an alleged "manifestly unlawful nuisance" (trouble manifestement illicite).

The claimants sought an injunction requiring Auchan E-commerce France to bring its website (auchan.fr) and mobile application into 100% compliance with France's General Accessibility Improvement Framework (RGAA), subject to a daily penalty of €1,000 after a 30-day period. They also sought an order suspending the site and app until compliance was achieved (under a €5,000 penalty per violation), an advance payment of €50,000 for damages, publication of the order on Auchan's homepage, and cost awards.

Findings on Technical Deficiencies

The court observed substantial accessibility shortcomings. Out of 19 sections listed in the website's accessibility declaration, non-compliances had a "strong to major" impact on 13 sections, a "strong" impact on one, and moderate-to-strong impacts across several others. Such defects prevent or impede access to core features. Additionally, an October 2023 internal audit of the Auchan mobile app revealed an overall low level of accessibility due to recurring non-compliances.

Legal Grounds and the Revenue Threshold

Despite noting the enterprise's apparent lack of interest in digital accessibility, the court ruled that no summary injunction could be granted because no clear breach of legal rules had been established.

Under Article 47 of Law No. 2005-102 of February 11, 2005, and Article 2 of Decree No. 2019-768 of July 24, 2019, private companies must ensure digital accessibility only if their average annual revenue in France exceeds €250 million over the three preceding financial years.

The claimants invoked Article L.412-13 of the French Consumer Code—which implements EU accessibility rules—and general non-discrimination principles under Law No. 2008-496 and the UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. The court found that:

  • The wording in Article L.412-13 ("without prejudice to Articles 47 and 48 of Law No. 2005-102") does not override the existing statutory rules or their implementing regulations, including the €250 million revenue threshold.
  • Auchan E-commerce France provided evidence showing that its average annual revenue under the regulatory criteria fell below this €250 million limit.
  • General statutory non-discrimination principles and international conventions do not modify or set aside the specific statutory scope and threshold defined by Article 47.

Outcome and Orders

Finding that no flagrant violation of law existed to justify emergency intervention, the judge found no basis for summary relief (n'y avoir lieu à référé). The court dismissed all requests for injunctions, penalties, damages, and site suspensions.

The associations were ordered to bear the procedural costs in equal halves. Requests for legal expenses under Article 700 of the Code of Civil Procedure were rejected, leaving each party to bear its own legal fees.

The full decision is available in the database of the Cour de cassation.

All news

Newsletter

Accessibility news straight to your inbox

New laws and deadlines, court rulings, enforcement and WCAG changes. A short summary once a week, and an e-mail straight away when something important happens. Unsubscribe at any time.

  • Important changes straight away, the rest in a weekly summary
  • New laws and compliance deadlines
  • Court rulings and enforcement actions
  • Changes to WCAG and other standards

Choose nothing to get everything. Pick categories if you only want some of them.