All news

French Court Orders Retailer Carrefour France to Remedy Digital Accessibility Deficiencies

A summary judge at the Tribunal judiciaire de Caen ordered Carrefour France to bring its e-commerce website and app into compliance with accessibility rules within six months or face daily fines.

On June 4, 2026, the summary judge (juge des référés) at the Tribunal judiciaire de Caen issued an injunction directing Carrefour France to make its online retail services compliant with accessibility rules. The proceedings were initiated by two disability advocacy groups, Association ApiDV (accompagner, promouvoir, intégrer les déficients visuels) and Association Droit pluriel, after formal notice served on July 9, 2025, produced no satisfactory response.

Legal Grounds and Presumption of Non-Compliance

Under Article 47 of French Law No. 2005-102 of February 11, 2005, and Article L. 412-13 of the French Consumer Code (code de la consommation), companies with annual revenue exceeding 250 million euros must provide digital communication and e-commerce services that comply with statutory accessibility requirements. These rules became mandatory for commercial e-commerce services on June 28, 2025, following the transposition of the European Accessibility Act (Directive 2019/882) and the ministerial order of October 9, 2023.

Pursuant to Article D. 412-59 of the Consumer Code, compliance with European standard EN 301 549 creates a legal presumption of conformity with statutory accessibility obligations.

Carrefour France's public accessibility statements, evaluated through the national RGAA framework (Référentiel Général d'Amélioration de l'Accessibilité), established an overall compliance rate of only 71.21%. The claimant organizations identified 19 distinct non-compliance points with minor to major impact, including:

  • Missing or irrelevant text alternatives for informative images and image-based text;
  • Frames lacking descriptors for assistive technologies;
  • Insufficient color contrast ratios between text and background;
  • Unclear or context-less link descriptions;
  • Scripts and dynamic interface components incompatible with assistive technologies or inaccessible via keyboard navigation;
  • Improper HTML semantics, missing header hierarchy, and inconsistent document structure;
  • Low focus indicator visibility and interface elements requiring horizontal scrolling at 256 pixels;
  • Unlabeled form inputs, inadequate error control, and missing auto-fill purpose metadata;
  • Landmark and content-grouping areas that cannot be bypassed or reached directly.

Ruling on Disproportionate Burden and Remedies

The court observed that commercial websites cannot be merely partially accessible, but must be fully compliant. While non-compliance creates a rebuttable presumption that statutory requirements are violated, the retailer failed to substantiate its defense of disproportionate burden under Article L. 412-13 of the Consumer Code.

The judge ruled that the lack of full accessibility constitutes a manifestly unlawful disturbance (trouble manifestement illicite). Consequently, the court:

  • Enjoined Carrefour France to bring its e-commerce website and mobile application into compliance with the accessibility requirements of the October 9, 2023 order;
  • Imposed a penalty of 500 euros per day of delay, starting six months after the issuance of the order;
  • Ordered Carrefour France to pay a provisional sum of 10,000 euros in moral damages jointly to the claimant associations;
  • Awarded 3,000 euros for legal costs under Article 700 of the French Code of Civil Procedure, alongside procedural costs.

However, the court dismissed the associations' request to suspend access to the retailer's website and application, deeming a complete shutdown disproportionate and contrary to the general public interest. The request to publish the ruling on the homepage of Carrefour France was also rejected.

All news

Newsletter

Accessibility news straight to your inbox

New laws and deadlines, court rulings, enforcement and WCAG changes. A short summary once a week, and an e-mail straight away when something important happens. Unsubscribe at any time.

  • Important changes straight away, the rest in a weekly summary
  • New laws and compliance deadlines
  • Court rulings and enforcement actions
  • Changes to WCAG and other standards

Choose nothing to get everything. Pick categories if you only want some of them.